Here’s the thing:
You feel under siege from being criticized about your behavior and you conclude that means enmity against your own "self".
It isn’t, no matter how much someone could be upset by what you say, it’s not a crusade against you.
What is being attacked is the self deception bull narrative that you tell yourself and need to be validated to any extent in order to pursue what your own conscience feels awful and wrong, shutting her up in this manner, so the ego can prosper while the shame stays at bay, relatively easy to manage.
Because this ain’t about your wife, this is about your wounds.
When you betray and deceive others you are first of all betraying and deceiving yourself.
You are your very same abuser, the victim of yourself. The unresolved issues that allow for that are what you should fight against to regain center and peace.
Your wife or the other woman don’t even matter in this picture. They are just collateral damage. Their wounds or trauma are a separate matter.
Your worst enemy is somewhere else, within, incarnated in the ego you built, and doesn’t want to let you go because there’s some issue unresolved that keeps you scared of embracing your true worth, for it fears is worthless, not enough.
You are enough, you are worthy, you just need to embrace it and let go of the rest and you will finally get clarity.
There is no outcome to long for, once you are in your center.
see I am not addressing your narrative because it is pointless. You build this narrative not as a defense from the bites of shame trying to keep remorse in check during a healing journey, this narrative is constructed to be a justification to keep pursuing the same behaviors that caused pain, in you, in others.
That’s is why the cognitive dissonance is so strikingly evident.
I could repeat to you that a friend is never coming before a partner, or that threatening to harm or shoot yourself if you can’t keep the other woman (and your wife, but she always comes second) in your life it’s a neon sign that this is not "just friends".
I can explain it all, sexual and romantic entanglement doesn’t need physical intercourse to be such. Also that the affair partner having sexual relationships with others doesn’t crush you ain’t the gotcha you think it is: is the standard, affairs are not a relationship, it’s betrayal of people who are in a relationship.
There is no exclusivity they are already cheating! If it was they would first leave their partners and then pursue each other to see if it clicks.
But it would be a wasted time, pointing out hypocrisy or inconsistency never works, a person doesn’t change mind, they only can accept what they already desire.
You are right now ready to accept anything that can support the narrative and outcome you want. You are blind and deaf to anything else.
I am not seeing right now if you can understand that the feedback, even when you get slapped with a 2x4 , is to help you to stop abusing and deceiving yourself. To find peace no clarity.
I simply don’t see you are there just yet. Only you can decide to.
Betrayal is a kind of abuse that curses your life as well, not only those who are victims of being betrayed, the betrayer is also a victim of their choice.
You use religion as a shield, in dissonance with it being the very same religion who puts traitors in the deepest circle of hell.
Judas has a special place for betrayal was not followed by guilt and making amends, but by shame and suicide.
The avoidance of guilt is what doomed him from forgiveness.
You would not even register this, but you are following that example of avoidance.
Hopefully you stopped the suicidal thing because it is nothing good nor farming you empathy. And is a deadly sin for the Catholic Church.
You claim to be driven by the faith, then by all means I would trust you would try to amend, not heading towards filling the deadly sin cheevos as an achievement completionists.
You already have empathy.
Your wife has sympathy but she is not here, nobody can help her.
No matter how unpleasant it may seem, the feedback you are getting is intended to help you feel good.
Not like shit. That’s the direction you are taking, and confirmation bias of the narrative will just drag you in deeper.
Anyway I expect complete denial, it is fine, I can’t crack the armor of the mask you chosen.
But you can. You can nail that fucker like a pro.
But it is only you who holds that power.
You can be saved, but you must want to save yourself first.
Good luck.