Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Franchesca

Wayward Side :
Follow-up about the groundbreaking study about which I posted over at General.

default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 12:14 AM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

We haven't been able to find a way to accommodate Retrouvaille. I'd like us to try it. I just dunno how. We have 2 kids--neither old enough to take care of themselves for a full day, let alone a weekend. Our moms are alive but not out of state and not circumstantially in positions to help us. Our dads are dead. My brother in law is dead (cancer). His widow lives out of state and she has kids to tend. My brother and his new W live across the country. Neither my W nor I have any friends. We have a nanny who helps, but--for a whole weekend? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

We're stuck.

I've fought the limerence fight elsewhere. Short version of my argument. The author who created that term said it didn't apply to platonic relationships. My relationship with her was never romantic or sexual in the smallest way. I don't covet her or lust over my OW even in the mind. Therefore, by the originator's definition, I cannot be limerent toward my OW. Let me tell you all--briefly--what I want: I want to know whether she ever found a new job. What line of work she's in now. Is she happy? What's new with our mutual online friends. How did the date go with the man from Zimbabwe? (I'm hoping great!) How is her flatmate's dog? Did she ever explore the faints she took or the massive headaches she suffers? (Her dad died of an unforeseen ruptured brain aneurysm.) May I send her some American Christmas cookies? I want to tell her how my W did something really sweet and loving for me this past weekend when I was ill with Influenza. How work has been tough for me lately. How my kids are growing up so fast, but I'm super proud of them. NOT: R U DTF by text? NOT: What're you wearing? NOT: Check out my latest dick-pic? NOT: Send me nudes?

I have told my W and our MC that I continue to hope some day to be reunited with my OW in friendship. They both allowed that hope to remain. Through 6 months of NC, that hope has not waivered. I have consciously kept my pain over my OW and thought over her under wraps to minimize trauma to my W through healing. However, I had to remind my W of that the other day when she said something that made me think: she might be assuming I no longer have this hope I still have. Deeply. I sent her a text and we moved on. I gather she wasn't pleased, but we didn't actually speak about the message. We are still pursuing R through joint MC and I am getting IC. I wish I could say we are further along than we are on the journey to full R after what has felt like forever, but it's hard to R with a spouse when we are hardly together and my W bottles up all her emotions. (She's quite boastful of how well she does so, in fact.) If and when R succeeds, I won't just immediately launch into my OW's DMs. That's never been the plan. I want to review meticulous plans with my W and our joint MC to ensure every base is covered to ensure absolute safety of the M and--of secondary, but nontrivial, importance--the friendship. I am willing to suffer almost any burden. Any inconvenience. To find out how my OW's flatmate's dog is doing, for God's sake! There is absolutely NOTHING remotely romantic or sexual about my intentions.

Actually, InkHulk, I started a thread about a journal article. Others have made this about me.

BluerThanBlue, you seem to know your Bible. You have accused me of much. You have said so.

[This message edited by Unconventional at 12:32 AM, Wednesday, November 18th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 183   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909690
default

BackfromtheStorm ( member #86900) posted at 10:39 AM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

Here’s the thing:

You feel under siege from being criticized about your behavior and you conclude that means enmity against your own "self".

It isn’t, no matter how much someone could be upset by what you say, it’s not a crusade against you.

What is being attacked is the self deception bull narrative that you tell yourself and need to be validated to any extent in order to pursue what your own conscience feels awful and wrong, shutting her up in this manner, so the ego can prosper while the shame stays at bay, relatively easy to manage.

Because this ain’t about your wife, this is about your wounds.

When you betray and deceive others you are first of all betraying and deceiving yourself.

You are your very same abuser, the victim of yourself. The unresolved issues that allow for that are what you should fight against to regain center and peace.

Your wife or the other woman don’t even matter in this picture. They are just collateral damage. Their wounds or trauma are a separate matter.

Your worst enemy is somewhere else, within, incarnated in the ego you built, and doesn’t want to let you go because there’s some issue unresolved that keeps you scared of embracing your true worth, for it fears is worthless, not enough.

You are enough, you are worthy, you just need to embrace it and let go of the rest and you will finally get clarity.

There is no outcome to long for, once you are in your center.

see I am not addressing your narrative because it is pointless. You build this narrative not as a defense from the bites of shame trying to keep remorse in check during a healing journey, this narrative is constructed to be a justification to keep pursuing the same behaviors that caused pain, in you, in others.

That’s is why the cognitive dissonance is so strikingly evident.
I could repeat to you that a friend is never coming before a partner, or that threatening to harm or shoot yourself if you can’t keep the other woman (and your wife, but she always comes second) in your life it’s a neon sign that this is not "just friends".

I can explain it all, sexual and romantic entanglement doesn’t need physical intercourse to be such. Also that the affair partner having sexual relationships with others doesn’t crush you ain’t the gotcha you think it is: is the standard, affairs are not a relationship, it’s betrayal of people who are in a relationship.
There is no exclusivity they are already cheating! If it was they would first leave their partners and then pursue each other to see if it clicks.

But it would be a wasted time, pointing out hypocrisy or inconsistency never works, a person doesn’t change mind, they only can accept what they already desire.

You are right now ready to accept anything that can support the narrative and outcome you want. You are blind and deaf to anything else.

I am not seeing right now if you can understand that the feedback, even when you get slapped with a 2x4 , is to help you to stop abusing and deceiving yourself. To find peace no clarity.

I simply don’t see you are there just yet. Only you can decide to.

Betrayal is a kind of abuse that curses your life as well, not only those who are victims of being betrayed, the betrayer is also a victim of their choice.

You use religion as a shield, in dissonance with it being the very same religion who puts traitors in the deepest circle of hell.

Judas has a special place for betrayal was not followed by guilt and making amends, but by shame and suicide.

The avoidance of guilt is what doomed him from forgiveness.

You would not even register this, but you are following that example of avoidance.
Hopefully you stopped the suicidal thing because it is nothing good nor farming you empathy. And is a deadly sin for the Catholic Church.

You claim to be driven by the faith, then by all means I would trust you would try to amend, not heading towards filling the deadly sin cheevos as an achievement completionists.

You already have empathy.
Your wife has sympathy but she is not here, nobody can help her.

No matter how unpleasant it may seem, the feedback you are getting is intended to help you feel good.

Not like shit. That’s the direction you are taking, and confirmation bias of the narrative will just drag you in deeper.

Anyway I expect complete denial, it is fine, I can’t crack the armor of the mask you chosen.
But you can. You can nail that fucker like a pro.

But it is only you who holds that power.
You can be saved, but you must want to save yourself first.

Good luck.

You are welcome to send me a PM if you think I can help you. I respond when I can.

posts: 1253   ·   registered: Jan. 7th, 2026   ·   location: Poland
id 8909702
default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 11:48 AM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

Ironically, Polish has--I think--better words than English to describe my relationship with my OW.

I don’t speak or read Polish, though my OW has long lived in Poland (I live in the USA), so I apologize if I slightly misuse the terms. Still, I believe it is linguistically and culturally accurate for me to say that she was moja bardzo bliska przyjaciółka ("my very close female friend"). I understand that expression to capture both the depth of our closeness and the strictly platonic nature of the bond. Given that your language naturally distinguishes casual acquaintances from a deep, non-romantic connection--in Polish, a wyjątkowa przyjaźń ("exceptional friendship")--it has long surprised me that you, of all people here, have fought me on characterizing my relationship with my OW as a friendship!

Maybe you doubt the sincerity of my admission that I committed infidelity with a friend through acts of friendship?

But I do admit that! I admit that the friendship became too important! That it violated my marital vows. That it could not sinlessly be restored at such a depth. For her part, my friend was always respectful of my family--she believed my wife was okay with how emotionally close we were, and the moment she learned otherwise, she ended the friendship herself. I am committed to a dial-back in the friendship's depth--not because I want that for its own sake or because moja bardzo bliska przyjaciółka was or is undeserving of my trust or my loyalty, but because my deepest loyalty absolutely belongs to my wife. Purgatory-like mind-fuck though it has been, I have been white-knuckling no-contact with my OW for 6 months (earlier counts were slightly off by accident; I apologize) as a kind of penance in a desperate attempt to create a safe space within which my W can tentatively baby step her way back into the center of my heart and marriage so my M can heal. I have not tried to force a deadline for my W to return to being even a source of meager support for me.

However, anyone who thinks I am going to forsake forever the hope of eventually recovering my OW to an honest, open, scaled-back friendship--actually the only meaningful friendship (besides my W's) that I have had in 30 years of adulthood--when waaaaay less restrictive measures would surely be marriage safety ensuring--is absolutely deluding themselves.

Do I want to have my wife be my queen? The unchallenged and undeniable emotional center of my Universe? Absolutely! Will I go to extreme measures--and pay obscene prices--to ensure my W's absolute safety from further infidelity? You can bet your last dollar on that!

[This message edited by Unconventional at 4:11 PM, Wednesday, November 18th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 183   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909708
default

KitchenDepth5551 ( member #83934) posted at 3:57 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

anyone who thinks I am going to forsake forever my OW--

...

--is absolutely deluding themselves.

This might be a strange thing to say on this website, but doesn't this make your situation so much simpler and easier?

You've decided you will not give this relationship up. Make that clear to your wife. Keep making it clear. Your will not accept any other outcomes. That is your right. She will accept that, or she will not. The next step will logically follow for you both.

EDIT:

anyone who thinks I am going to forsake forever the hope of eventually recovering my OW to an honest, open, scaled-back friendship

Ok. You have edited your post after I made mine to change the meaning. GotTheMorbs does that too. Things that make you go hmmm. shocked

[This message edited by KitchenDepth5551 at 4:38 PM, Wednesday, November 18th]

posts: 348   ·   registered: Sep. 27th, 2023
id 8909719
default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 4:57 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

KitchenDepth --

Here's why I haven't--and won't--follow that advice:

Reason number 1:

Infidelity is traumatizing to a BS. Someone struggling with acute trauma cannot fairly be asked to know what they will be willing to accept after 2 or 5 years or recovery time. My wife already knows EVERYTHING about my relationship with my OW. I have held back absolutely nothing. But, this one truth--that, if my OW will have me back in friendship (she might not), I absolutely insist upon having that friendship again (newly in a healthy form)--is just outright toxic to embarking on a journey toward R. So, we're going to work toward R and then, if I still feel as I still do now, I will tell my W about my need for my OW. In my defense, I assure you that every single last step I have been making to foster, facilitate, and further R is made for absolutely no purpose except to accomplish R with my W.

Reason number 2:

MCs almost universally insist upon permanent NC between WSs and OPs as a condition of MC. That's not been because of controlled trial evidence. It's been because that practice was part of an approach that worked to support R for many couples following infidelity. That inspired a tradition that got taught from MC-teacher to MC-student again through generations. There has long been anecdotal evidence that NC isn't actually necessary to support M R universally after affairs. For instance, As sometimes produce children. Under such circumstances, a WS and AP may have to remain in regular dialogue. Yet some Ms can enjoy R despite such challenging additional wrinkles. Furthermore, jobs cannot always be capriciously forsaken. Sometimes, a WS and an AP continue to work with each other, yet the WS's M may still experience R. Those situations have traditionally been seen as "the exceptions" rather than "the models;" the "dirty little secret, don't look over there--move along, people" success stories that MCs tend to steer the general public away from studying. For the first time, an admittedly very imperfect research study by no less an infidelity recovery scholar than Gottman himself has recently cast a tiny beam of light on a segment of the population trying to heal from infidelity without cutting contact between a WS and an OP. I recently posted about that paper in the General forum of this website. However, that paper is so new that it remains the case that nearly all practicing MCs insist upon NC between a WS and an OP if M R is the couple's stated goal of MC. I believe there are special circumstances applicable in my case that justify the bypassing of the rule on NC between a WS and an OP. However, if I insist overtly now on eventually returning to contact with my OW, I have cause to suspect we will get shuffled involuntarily into discernment counseling or I would be told go do IC until you change, then come back. Well... I'm not going to change. But we absolutely need MC to fix root problems in out M to support R! I suppose I could resort to seeking counseling through a "polyamorous-affirming MC," but as monogamy is fully my goal, I think resorting to someone as an MC who does that kind of work would set a pretty discouraging message to my W.

So, sure... total 1000% transparency would be nice. But doing so would not achieve the ends I am seeking.

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 183   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909722
default

SeekingWhatever ( new member #87613) posted at 5:25 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

So, sure... total 1000% transparency would be nice. But doing so would not achieve the ends I am seeking.

This is manipulation. You are manipulating your wife's reality to get what you want. That is cruel behavior, even if done with a hug and a kiss. Maybe even especially then.

Good luck, and take care of yourself.

sure as the sun in your eyes / love always returns

posts: 15   ·   registered: Jul. 22nd, 2026
id 8909727
default

LittleMonk ( member #86661) posted at 6:10 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

I have to be honest. I'm not entirely sure why you are here.

You seem remarkably unwilling to consider anyone else's perspective. You have repeatedly struggled to define your relationship with this other woman, alternately describing it as infidelity, platonic friendship, not an affair, and various other vagaries seemingly designed to accommodate whatever conclusion you're trying to reach.

You acknowledge that your wife knows you hope to resume this relationship, yet you intend to withhold the fact that you consider its eventual restoration nonnegotiable. You've even explained why: complete transparency would interfere with achieving your desired outcome.

That is not reconciliation. It's manipulation through selective disclosure.

You are deliberately withholding information your wife needs to make informed decisions about her own marriage. You are attempting to secure reconciliation on terms she has not knowingly accepted, while reserving the right to introduce those terms once she is more deeply invested.

You seem far more concerned with finding a justification for what you have already decided than examining why you remain so attached to a relationship you have acknowledged violated your marital boundaries.

You have made it abundantly clear that you're going to do what you are going to do. So what, exactly, are you seeking here? Understanding? Perspective? Approval?

There are other forums where you might find the validation you're looking for. r/adultery or AITAH come to mind.

But if you're genuinely interested in reconciliation, perhaps the place to start is recognizing that your wife's agency matters just as much as your own desires. She cannot meaningfully consent to a reconciliation whose terms you intentionally conceal from her.

You cannot build an honest marriage through continued deception, regardless of how carefully you define the words involved.

- LM BH Reconciled

Dday: 12/2024

"The hardest cage to sit in is the one where you hold the key, knowing exactly what freedom looks like on the outside."

posts: 111   ·   registered: Oct. 10th, 2025   ·   location: North Carolina
id 8909734
default

 Unconventional (original poster member #87720) posted at 6:53 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

KitchenDepth --

anyone who thinks I am going to forsake forever the hope of eventually recovering my OW to an honest, open, scaled-back friendship

Ok. You have edited your post after I made mine to change the meaning.

Yes, I edited that post way more than usual today, and I plead guilty to causing the confusion. I apologize for making edits that undercut your response. The site lagged for a while right as I was submitting my final update, so I didn't realize my changes would clash with what you had just posted. Had I realized it, I would have just written a new reply instead. Again, I'm sorry for what happened.

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 183   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909736
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy